Home > Linux, NetBSD > RAID and external USB backup on NetBSD 5

RAID and external USB backup on NetBSD 5

I recently had to change my “storage policy”…

A failed drive in my RAID1 set of 2 disks, and brand new disks coming up forced me to 😉 So here I am sharing two facts that have wasted my time recently. Hopefully it would help some to avoid these hassles, or at least plan more time for it.

First : I followed the NetBSD guide to setup my RAID back when I was on NetBSD3 probably. Things where a bit different from now that I have a 5 fully upgraded version, but anyway it still works. Problems is to be that I have the right same geometry for my disks in the RAID1, I did as they say on the official guide, which is copy the disklabel of disk 1 onto disk 2. and it works perfectly. Problem is : When you want to change the disk, both disklabels have same name and identifier, and if on top of that you have for some logistic reason to change the way the disks are plugged into the machine, it get much trickier to find out which drive you wanted to keep and which one you wanted to remove… So I had to “fix” my disklabels, and put different meaningful identifiers, so I could use them to properly identify which disks I wanted to pull out of my RAIDset.

Second : For my backup strategy, as my RAID set was previously “under-used”, meaning there was a lot more free space than I actually needed, I used to backup stuff inside the RAID itself. Even if it is discouraged for obvious reason, a RAID1 mirroring was enough to ensure my data, so I just wanted to be able to go dig up old configuration files and revert some setup, so just keeping the files, even in the same disk, made some sense.
Now that my disk usage is getting higher, and hard drive prices are getting lower, it s becoming worth it to get an external USB drive. I naively thought that just plugin it, and pointing my rsnapshot config to the appropriate mount point would be enough. Error.
RSnapshot uses hardlinks in order to minimize the duplicates of files into the different backups, and therefore cannot work on the preconfigured FAT partition on that drive. I expected that, so I plug that USB dirve in my ubuntu laptop, uses gparted to make a big ext2fs partition, and unplug it. From there I expected i would work. Well it didnt. As stated in the mailing list, at the time I am writing this, ext2fs has problem being mounted on the netbsd-5-0 branch, although this has been fixed in netbsd-5. I really wanted to use ext2fs for my external backup just because it would make it so easier to retrieve data on another “non-BSD” computer, I now have to upgrade to a netbsd-5 branch, rebuild everything, install the newly built OS, and reboot. Extremely easy to do since I document and script all these tasks. Just time consuming…

Advertisements
Categories: Linux, NetBSD Tags: , , ,
  1. 2010/01/24 at 16:32

    Mmm seems in fact that mount_ext2fs cannot mount the filesystem made on my ubuntu by gparted for some reason. So I made a new one on NetBSD with newfs_ext2fs and then the mount worked. The problem referred in mail was in fact about uid/gid change not happening.

  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: